Finally had a chance to put these to the test. I did a three hour ride in continuous light to medium rain where the high temp hit 37 f. I wore these over insulated bib tights and was comfortably warm and stayed absolutely dry. I did not have excessive perspiration buildup. They are easy to get on over shoes/shoe covers with the side zippers and zipper at the waist. I am 5ï¿½11 and 195 lbs. the XL fit great over tights. They are a bit baggy in the knee area which should allow for knee pads and had plenty of length.
Only drawback I could imagine is that they are heavier than say my Gore paclite but the more substantial material seems like it will wear better in my opinion. If your goal is super light and packable there are better options but if you want to stay dry you canï¿½t go wrong with these.