I thought I would never find something to replace my favorite and my runner up, but this wins. No tingle, effective, can use less because of consistency (thinner and spreads easily), and washes out well. Plus you get a lot in a tub for a good price. Try it!
Have tried all the other creams and this one is the best. No tingling, nothing gooey and sticky, and no rash. Application is easy and it works for me on 4 hour rides, no problem.