Replaced and OLD pair of Northwave Fahrenheit shoes with the Sidi's. What an upgrade! They are easier to get on and off, stiffer and just as warm. A little pricey, but they are Sidi's...you get what you pay for.
I've never had riding boots before, probably because I live in Alabama. I decided to buy a pair and I've really enjoyed them this year. I ride them in sub 50 degree temps. Lightweight and comfortable, warm not hot, great shoe - rain or shine!
Used for the first rain ride in of the season in the Pacific Northwest, and a downpour at that. The footbed of the boots was pretty wet at the end of the ride, not sloshing but still wet. The cuffs on the boots do not provide a tight seal against all water leaking down. I expect to have to dry them out after a wet ride but still better and easier than an overboot. Now, what really kept my feet dry was the showers pass water proof socks I wore with this. If nothing else, get a pair of those if you ride in the rain.
Shoes are warm, which is a good thing. They are winter shoes. I have been out in 25degree temps with normal socks. I typically have issues with the cold so these get 5 starts for that. I found the high top to rub against my ankle the wrong way and I am still breaking them in. This is my issue. Shape of my foot ankle whatever. I do no think this is a flaw in the shoe design.
Have been commuting and doing longer winter rides with hour commute in low 20 degrees and toes did well. Longer or colder rides will need added covers. Fit is excellent.
Solid sole and cleat fit. Closure works well if you have nimble fingers and gloves off.
Ive used these on a dozen cold rides so far, including a three hour ride in the low 40s (38 to 45 (degrees F). Theyve performed well, keeping my feet off my mind. Cold feet are always going to be an issue in the winter months, but this option has been a big improvement over booties! I got caught out in the rain on one occasion and my feet remained dry and reasonably comfortable. The Wind Stopper is very effective! I no longer fear the freeze.
They fit somewhat loose, allowing for thick socks. Not an issue for me. I wear 45.5 Sidi road shoes size 46 has worked out well in these winter shoes.