Oregon winters are wet and chilly, and these boots make all the difference. I use them for road riding, with SPD pedals. They don't leak up through the cleats as some shoes do, and the shell is truly waterproof. I find them comfortable down to about 33 degrees, with thick socks. I've ridden in heavy rains for hours many times and they never leak... except, as with every winter shoe I've used, water can get in from the top, and the neoprene collar will soak up some water. But even after riding for several hours, this has not resulted in water leaking down into the shoe. If you're really hard-core about dryness, use gaiters to cover the upper shoe collar, and pull your rain pants down over the gaiters for a perfect seal. I do recommend getting the WIDE version, even for normal feet, as the "normal" fit version made my narrow feet feel pretty claustrophobic. Lastly, the soles are very good for walking, when you need to.
Use it at under 50 degrees since I tend to have cold feet. Don't care for the overboots.
Size is just a bit large that gives room for thicker socks.
nice shoe to work with.
