I wear a 10.5 and have a slightly wide foot, but can cram my foot into a normal width shoe. For those of you in this in-between situation, consider this shoe in Wide. I have just the right amount of space for my forefoot, I feel secure, and when I'm off the bike I don't have the weird foot pains that I had before with my normal-width shoes.
The cloth is also very comfortable, and the Boa is always great. Very light and stiff carbon sole, too. I bought on sale, which made the price just right.
I will say, the shoes seems to run a little long. My 10.5 should have been a 44, but I could have done a 43.5 and had a better fit. The extra room will be good for winter socks, however, so I'm keeping them.