I was skeptical about going to a soft case but several of my friends have the EVOC and they have never had any issues. Flew to Idaho with my full suspension mtb and the bike was in perfect shape and no damage. I'm very happy with this product.
Does everything it's meant to protective and easy to cart around. It's only fault is that it's still just a little bulky when transporting it empty, though that can be somewhat minimized by taking out the support stays.
I do really like this though.