I do lots of 6-7 hour rides, so everything matters in detail.
The padding on these gloves is a little thinner than others, but that's not a bad thing, it's still sufficient.
For me the best detail, critical, is that the gels don't have any sharp edges.
I've had gloves with gel 'blocks' and after a long day, all those 90 degree edges really start to dig into your hand.
I think any future pair will be velcro strap closure rather than pull on/off, but that's just a personal preference and makes no difference to the gloves performance.
Over the years I've tried quite a number of biking gloves. None of them really worked to relieve the numbness I would get on a long ride, so I finally just started riding without them. I decided to try these on a lark just to see if they'd make any difference--and I'm glad I did. They are the first pair of gloves I've owned that actually work. The stitching came open at the base of the thumb so I deducted one star for that. Easy sewing fix, but that shouldn't happen.
Most comfortable
I use them in warmer temps (45 degrees and above). I was initially concerned about no velcro tab however the elasticity of the glove allows a tight fit and and easy on and off. The overall look and feel of the gloves is great. I am confident my hands are well protected by these gloves.
Minimal padding. Tight fit. Would recommend for racers.
My go to gloves. I have four pair so I can rotate them between rides. I like that they don't have a clasp or velcro closure, just slip them on or off. The padding is dense enough to prevent numb hands but not too thick. I want a pair in every color.
Most comfortable
Very nice high quality bike gloves.
gloves has great padding, but the stitching between the thumb & forefinger has a knot that hurts/irritating after couples of hours of wearing.
Theses gloves are great. No problems with numb hands and great on those hot days.
Simply the best performing and fit glove I've ever owned, The padding works well and I love the pull tap and the absence of Velcro.
Looks good, feels right and provides cushioning - but it's a bear to remove after a hot summer ride.
Another great product from the folks at Castelli.