I love these discs. I replaced the Stock Tektros on my Trek FXS6. I put Shimano resin pads on too. I'll be further upgrading to Shimano XT calipers and levers. It'll be a sweet set up! .
As is true for other XT components, this rotor defines the intersection of superior performance at a reasonable cost. Excellent stopping power in all conditions. The only caveat is that one must be careful when truing these rotors - they can be irrevocably damaged if bent too far.